Wednesday, December 11, 2019

HR Director Santiago Malave Out? UPDATED

One of our members noticed today that the job of Human Resources Director had been posted a week ago on the Town's website, you can find the posting at this link. Though we haven't seen any confirmation, we can only assume this means current HR Director Santiago Malave, who's at the center of the current Sergeant test scandal, and previously the Fire Department promotional exam scandal, is on his way out.

The timing of his departure is intriguing since we're less than a week a way from a hearing in Superior Court where we will argue for the forced release of the evaluator notes and score sheets from the Sergeant's exam that he's been fighting tooth and nail to keep hidden. Of course he could be leaving for any number of reasons, perhaps he's jumping ship before the documents come out and reveal something he or his subordinates did, or the Mayor could be forcing him out, or maybe he just found a better job elsewhere that'll pay him more than the $105,622 salary East Hartford gives him.

Either way Mr. Malave's potential departure is a great thing for our Union and every other Town Union. Aside from his botching of multiple promotional exams, he has acted as nothing more than a rubber stamp for the Chief's decisions during the grievance process where he's supposed to be a neutral arbiter. During my involvement with the Union since 2014 Mr. Malave has never once sided with our Union in any of his Step 2 grievance decisions, instead agreeing with the Chief every time. We've appealed almost all of his rulings to the Labor Board which has overturned Malave's decisions one hundred percent of the time. That's right, every single decision he's ruled on that we've appealed has been overturned. This includes one ruling where he told me to my face after the hearing that he agreed with the Union's position, but then issued his ruling in favor of the Town because I assume he was afraid to go against the Chief of Police.

Mr. Malave's refusal to grant a fair and impartial hearing has wasted hundreds of hours and tens of thousands of dollars of both taxpayer and Union funds by forcing us to take grievances before the Labor Board that could have easily been resolved at the HR level had he done his job properly. We can only hope that whoever replaces him will do the job correctly and give the Unions a fair hearing when we go before him or her so we're not constantly running over to Wethersfield. It would be a huge plus if they know how to run a promotional exam without getting dragged to Court too.

UPDATE: We're hearing Malave is out mid-January before the decision from Superior Court should come down. The line we're hearing from the Admin/Town Hall is that this departure has been planned for at least a year. Of course this makes no sense at all, if you know a critical Department head is on his way out for a year, why would you wait until one month before his departure to post for his job? Don't you think they'd want ample time for qualified candidates to apply, and be interviewed and vetted before the spot goes vacant rather than doing it at the last minute? File that one under "not buying it."

16 comments:

Anonymous said...

CLEAN HOUSE!!! WHO'S NEXT?????

Anonymous said...

Keep spreading your lies with your tinfoils hat, you know you got nothing and now are desperate to smears anybody to make your sick and racist and sexist agendas appear legit. The truth is coming out soon and you will be proved wrong when you see that hard work pays off no matter how bad you don’t like it. You should face the fact that this hole thing looks bad because the unions sticking up for their buddies and spending monies they should be spending on important things for once. Maybe the union should get a vote of confidence in them huh?

Anonymous said...

In response to the above poster, if Courtney is so confident in her perfect score shouldnt she be fighting along with the Union for the release of the papers so she can prove its legitimate and get promoted instead of fighting to keep them secret and making false accusations?

Anonymous said...

There no evidence of cheating so create the rumor that there was because others aren’t as smart as they thought they were. Why is she the only one in history that has to PROVE her score when nobody else had to? Don’t matter in the end a lot of apologies coming soon fools.

Anonymous said...

There is no evidence of cheating because HR is hiding the results

It’s not that she is the only person to ever have to “prove” her results it s that this is the only test HR has done everything imaginable to not prove any thing

Past test takers only had to ask to see their test results

Think about it. This entire issue could be resolved with the showing of the score sheets. Time and money saved with the showing of the score sheets. No lawyers. No court. Just a simple Transparent resolution Why wouldn’t HR want this resolved as soon and as efficiently as possible. All they have to do. To end this entire debockle is show the score sheets. But they won’t. Maybe she is perfect. Maybe the others are all dumb. Show the score sheets.

Anonymous said...

Call it what you want it just a continuation of the hostility towards her that’s been documented to this date. Sad when someone can’t go to a retirement party without being harassed and threatened or the store to do something nice for a retiree and she harassed and threatened there too. It’s ok keep sticking up for your friends......

Anonymous said...

Cont...
Besides no one is asking for her results. The other test takers are asking for their own results. How can you not be shown your own results????

Anonymous said...

Harassment and threatening are crimes. Why didn’t she arrest the suspects.

Anonymous said...

You keep mentioning the "hard work" narrative. If she worked so hard, and is 28-30% smarter than 6 other experienced cops, why did she get 5th on the written? Stop being so basic dude. If you dont see the smoking gun here, you probably struggle to find PC at a shoplifter in custody. Dumb Dumb.

Anonymous said...

So now we are going from the appellants wanting to see their scores to her having to prove her scores. What an amazing twist. Way to pass the buck. And hostility towards her? Really? Are you joking? She has managed to piss off the nicest people here along the way. We are all just waiting to see the next posting which is hopefully her resignation.

Anonymous said...

Enough with the conspiracy theories. Its totally normal for people to resign on short notice while wrapped up in a scandal of their own doing. Why would you think this is anything but a totally legitimate, voluntary resignation?

Anonymous said...

Response to above:

Conspiracy theory that she couldn’t have gotten a perfect score or the town fixed the scores? Even the chief said he has seen perfect scores on oral panels...

Conspiracy theory the HR director is leaving because he did or knows of some type of dirty dealings with the scoring? Again the chief confirmed he was planning on leaving a year ago! Does that go for Hanlon also since he left a year early and knows all the lies and false supervisor complaints that are going NOWHERE because they know they are lies and retaliation?!

Conspiracy theory she was given training and spots unfairly although the qualifications speak for themselves?? Just like how supervisors are denying fto to proactive cops because they don’t like them and abuse their power?

Get real and look at the facts before you make stupid assumptions. When this is all done and the TRUTH comes out people will be embarrassed for their actions and have to answer for them to everyone!

Anonymous said...

So then prove everyone wrong and show the test sheets. Ohhhh. They won’t don that

Anonymous said...

Is it hard to type in the third person or does the narcissism make it easier?

Anonymous said...

The Chief saw perfect scores in Hartford... a city known for hook ups and dirty tests...where Malave used to work...a city known for corruption and scandal...where mayors get imprisoned. Do your homework. If you did, you wouldn't get 5th on the written. You are young, inexperienced, and you have shown a sneak peak of your behavior as a supervisor already. Just apply elsewhere and learn from all this.

Anonymous said...

To the first poster...
I don’ts knows whats you ares tryings to says...I was too distracted by your atrocious grammar.
I love the “monies” - it almost sounds like you are a Nigerian prince!